Once you get past the first three Silent Hill games, theres a noticeable gulf in fondness and adoration for the rest. Still, even Silent Hill Downpour has its fans (raises hand) and there are some genuinely underappreciated entries in the Silent Hill franchise and ten years ago, Silent Hill: Homecoming became one of them.
Source: N4G PC Ten Years On: A Look Back At The Underappreciated Silent Hill: Homecoming