If it was not clear yet, Shenmue III is not for everyone. In addition, it seems its mechanics are simply too old-fashioned, almost anachronistic. It takes time and patience. Previous connection to the series is the deciding factor.
Yu Suzuki and his team did that which was not thought possible. The big comeback of the feeling of the day. With everything that goes with it – positive and negative. But this also reveals the whole hubris of this game, which is likely to polarize like no other in recent times. For some, it is the fulfillment of a dream, for the other stale game design in a nicer garb.
Source: N4G PC Shenmue III review | GamePro Germany